??Headers??

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • J10blues
    258 I6
    • Mar 21, 2014
    • 395

    ??Headers??

    And yet another "newby" question.....although I know we can do whatever we want to our rigs but I'm trying to decide if I want to install exhaust headers and was wondering if it's imperative that HEADERS be included if a 360 engine is being upgraded with an eddy 4bbl intake/carb,better camshaft, pistons,etc. for the sake of a sweater street performance, absolutely no racing venture here, just the frequent occasional pride ride!LOL!
    I know it's definitely advisable to run dual exhaust for better flow but is using the oem manifold not kosher in the performance world? Any input from the engine gurus are greatly appreciated. Perhaps this is more of a "if it were me question".

    Ben
    77 J10
    360 complete rebuild
    TH400
    Eddy Performer intake/Non EGR/CompCams 268 H
    Eddy 1406
    MSD 4AL/MSD 8519Dist/TFI coil
    Holley fuel pump
    MagnaFlow exhaust

    02 Jeep Wrangler TJ
    _________________________________________
    "Fast is Fine, Accuracy is Final, You Need To Be Slow..In a Hurry!" Wyatt Earp.
  • Ristow
    • Jan 20, 2006
    • 17292

    #2
    not mandatory. dual exhaust on stock manifolds is a decent upgrade.
    Originally posted by Hankrod
    Ristows right.................again,


    Originally posted by Fasts79Chief
    ... like the little 'you know what's' that you are.


    Originally posted by Fasts79Chief
    I LOVE how Ristow has stolen my comment about him ... "Quoted" it ... and made himself famous for being an ***hole to people. Hahahahahahahahahha!

    It's like you're unraveling a big cable-knit sweater that someone keeps knitting...and knitting...and knitting...and knitting...

    Comment

    • J10blues
      258 I6
      • Mar 21, 2014
      • 395

      #3
      Thanks Ristow!

      Ben
      77 J10
      360 complete rebuild
      TH400
      Eddy Performer intake/Non EGR/CompCams 268 H
      Eddy 1406
      MSD 4AL/MSD 8519Dist/TFI coil
      Holley fuel pump
      MagnaFlow exhaust

      02 Jeep Wrangler TJ
      _________________________________________
      "Fast is Fine, Accuracy is Final, You Need To Be Slow..In a Hurry!" Wyatt Earp.

      Comment

      • Tinkerjeep
        Banned
        • Mar 01, 2009
        • 3662

        #4
        Yep. x2. Less headache too if you can get the donuts to live.

        I'd clean out the inside of the manifold ports with a die-grinder and remove the cast-in "step" for the air injection tubes. they can hamper smooth flow.

        Last edited by Tinkerjeep; 06-26-2014, 09:17 AM.

        Comment

        • Texafornian
          258 I6
          • Apr 01, 2014
          • 257

          #5
          I have been doing a lot of research on this lately. From what my research indicates, there is really only one really good set of headers available for our 360's. They are made by Doug Thorley's. A pair that are ceramic coated are a little pricey but do enhance your low and mid range. Then again, for torque, its actually quite difficult to do better than the stock exhaust manifold. Yeah, its ugly and heavy, but they appear to have the best flow for what you want offroad, perhaps the Thorley are better, by a little. Now, if you go dueal exhaust, make sure you equalize them with an H pipe or you will lose torque. At least that's what I'm told by several quality custom ehaust shops.

          As for me, down the road I will probably go with the Thorley headers, no catalytic converter, 2-3/4" stainless tubing, H pipe, and dual Magna flows or perhaps Borla mufflers. All stainless. This will cost a bit, sooooo, we shall pinch pennies and use the stock manifold for now.
          ~Jim Sherlock~

          Comment

          • crazydog
            350 Buick
            • Nov 19, 2005
            • 865

            #6
            Originally posted by Texafornian
            Then again, for torque, its actually quite difficult to do better than the stock exhaust manifold.
            That is wrong.

            Research this thread.

            We have just completed a ABC comparison with ported Free Flow manifolds, Edelbrock Shotry headers #65873 and 1 5/8" long tube Hedmand Headers. The mill is a street 401 with dual quad 500 cfm Edelbrock carbs. on a Offy intake. It has '70 heads and the compression ratio is 10.2:1. Minimal porting was done, just smoothed out
            1979 Cherokee - Built 401, NV4500, Dana 300, 6" BJ's Lift w/ Bilstein 5125 Shocks, Goodyear Wrangler MT/R 35X12.5R15, Front Brake Upgrade w/ GM 2500 Calipers & EBC Pads, Rear Disc Brake Conversion, Z&M Jeeps Dash Insert w/ VDO Series 1 Gauges, Tad Rack, Ramsey Hidden Winch w/ REP8000, Hydroboost, CS140

            1967 J3500 - Making plans

            Comment

            • Texafornian
              258 I6
              • Apr 01, 2014
              • 257

              #7
              Doesn't sound wrong to me, after reading that thread. The headers tested didn't do all that much for the torque curve. They were a little better, but in my mind, the added gains versus the cost, was exactly what J10Blues was aking about. Note also, the headers tested were street versions. As for me, my Jeep is an exploration vehicle in the works. It will be offroad. From what I understand, the Thorley headers are designed for offroad usage in mind. Now? I'm no scientist, like many others, I do research, form opinions, ask questions, and try to make the best choice from there. You have a valid point that the headers tested showed some slight improvement, I figure its up to the end user whether or not the gains are worth the cost. IMO (humble) lol.
              ~Jim Sherlock~

              Comment

              • Tinkerjeep
                Banned
                • Mar 01, 2009
                • 3662

                #8
                The problem with Thorleys is two fold:
                1) they cost more than your Jeep is really worth;
                2) all of the "Y" fittings will crack out.

                I have personal experience with this. The older model Thorleys were not coated and did not have full length head flanges. I fixed mine so they did.





                The Y fittings cracked out twice in the 10 years they were on the J20 that became mine in 1996. ( I don't have pics of that.)

                I dislike the fit and finish of the Hedmen Hedders, but they flow better that Thorleys and they last longer since they are a 4-1 long tube. Now with ball-socket collectors. They do out flow stock exhaust manifolds. the manifolds in the article posted by SC/397 were ported out like the pic I showed in post #4. those ALMOST flowed as well as the Edelbrock Shorties, which don't flow as well as the crappy old Hedmans tested.

                From that thread and its test results here are the contenders in order from best to worst:
                1) old style Hedmans
                2)Edelbrock Shorties
                3) Ported stock manifolds

                Nothing else was tested. but Tri Ys are generally believed to not flow as well as 4-1 long tubes. I'd have to place the Tri-Ys between the Hedmans and the Eddies.

                An "Exploration Vehicle" is a new term for me. You want to explain the duties involved within this classification?
                Last edited by Tinkerjeep; 06-27-2014, 12:21 AM.

                Comment

                • J10blues
                  258 I6
                  • Mar 21, 2014
                  • 395

                  #9
                  Thanks for all the input guys! These are all good learning information. Texafornian, you are exactly spot-on for the reason I wanted to know if it was okay to use oem manifold instead of headers. My engine builder, Dale, was just wanting me to decide on headers or not? and whew! headers can get pretty pricey, especially because the rig is intended for racing at all. Crazydog, thank you for sharing that information as well, results of any research is always welcome knowledge. IMHO, I don't consider anyone on this forum is ever quite "wrong", because we all have different uses for our rigs and some of those uses don't require special innovations or precise science. Man, I love you guys....am I sure glad I joined this forum, everyone here has very special talents and knowledge! Again, thanks guys for all the help!

                  Ben
                  77 J10
                  360 complete rebuild
                  TH400
                  Eddy Performer intake/Non EGR/CompCams 268 H
                  Eddy 1406
                  MSD 4AL/MSD 8519Dist/TFI coil
                  Holley fuel pump
                  MagnaFlow exhaust

                  02 Jeep Wrangler TJ
                  _________________________________________
                  "Fast is Fine, Accuracy is Final, You Need To Be Slow..In a Hurry!" Wyatt Earp.

                  Comment

                  • Texafornian
                    258 I6
                    • Apr 01, 2014
                    • 257

                    #10
                    Sure thing! In my vocabulary, an exploration vehicle is a vehicle that is intended to go just about anywhere. I plan on giving it enough power, torque, lift, flex, reliability, and equipment so that it can safely and reliably tackle almost any trail it will fit on, handle any road it comes across, ford any reasonably crossable body of water, traverse most bodies of sand, and do all of this with decent comfort, and a relaxing amount of reliability. I still enjoy single vehicle offroading. In order to be safe, not only will someone know where we are headed, but we will also carry a ham radio, cd radio, water, emergency rations, and a small group of widely usable tools. If I can ever afford it, my goal is to have a vehicle capable of reliably traversing the Pan American roadway from the US through South America. My Jeep won't be specialized for rock gardens, or dunes, etc. I'm going to strive for a Jeep that may not excel at any single thing, but is tough, reliable, and capable of conquering many environments. That is an exploration vehicle, in my mind. (Smile, its a beautiful day)
                    ~Jim Sherlock~

                    Comment

                    • DarkMonohue
                      Shakes hands with danger
                      • Jul 01, 2012
                      • 1145

                      #11
                      Originally posted by J10blues
                      for the sake of a sweater street performance
                      Reminds me of a couple of girls I used to know...



                      Anyway, as everyone else says, stock manifolds are fine, especially if you have the earlier style on the driver's side, which your '77 should. Flow is not a concern. Long-tube headers will make a bit more torque at low engine speeds due to the longer runners than stock manifolds, but it's not worth it for most people and most situations, given the higher cost and typical loss of durability.
                      '85 J20 Old Man Truck, bought @ 65K miles - not great, but better than walking.
                      Member, FSJ Prissy Restoration Association
                      High quality junk here: intro thread and slow build thread

                      Did you know? Willys is just Willis spelled differently, but pronounced the same. Neither Willy nor his apostrophe are involved.

                      Comment

                      • J10blues
                        258 I6
                        • Mar 21, 2014
                        • 395

                        #12
                        Originally posted by DarkMonohue
                        Reminds me of a couple of girls I used to know...



                        Anyway, as everyone else says, stock manifolds are fine, especially if you have the earlier style on the driver's side, which your '77 should. Flow is not a concern. Long-tube headers will make a bit more torque at low engine speeds due to the longer runners than stock manifolds, but it's not worth it for most people and most situations, given the higher cost and typical loss of durability.

                        Haha!! You caught that?? You spelling nazi!! Anyway, thanks for the input.

                        Ben
                        77 J10
                        360 complete rebuild
                        TH400
                        Eddy Performer intake/Non EGR/CompCams 268 H
                        Eddy 1406
                        MSD 4AL/MSD 8519Dist/TFI coil
                        Holley fuel pump
                        MagnaFlow exhaust

                        02 Jeep Wrangler TJ
                        _________________________________________
                        "Fast is Fine, Accuracy is Final, You Need To Be Slow..In a Hurry!" Wyatt Earp.

                        Comment

                        • Tinkerjeep
                          Banned
                          • Mar 01, 2009
                          • 3662

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Texafornian
                          Sure thing! In my vocabulary, an exploration vehicle is a vehicle that is intended to go just about anywhere. I plan on giving it enough power, torque, lift, flex, reliability, and equipment so that it can safely and reliably tackle almost any trail it will fit on, handle any road it comes across, ford any reasonably crossable body of water, traverse most bodies of sand, and do all of this with decent comfort, and a relaxing amount of reliability. I still enjoy single vehicle offroading. In order to be safe, not only will someone know where we are headed, but we will also carry a ham radio, cd radio, water, emergency rations, and a small group of widely usable tools. If I can ever afford it, my goal is to have a vehicle capable of reliably traversing the Pan American roadway from the US through South America. My Jeep won't be specialized for rock gardens, or dunes, etc. I'm going to strive for a Jeep that may not excel at any single thing, but is tough, reliable, and capable of conquering many environments. That is an exploration vehicle, in my mind. (Smile, its a beautiful day)
                          Sounds like my favorite kind of JEEP! A Good, all purpose on/off-road vehicle capable of surviving the Zombie Apocalypse!

                          For similar builds like Tex; I'd recommend for max reliability: ported manifolds, and getting rid of the stupid heat block-off on the passenger side. Also equalize the pipe outlet IDs to both make 2.25". I think one side is slightly smaller. I'd run a dual 2.25" Y into a single 3" pipe to consolidate space and maximize flow for high-speed sand...also reduces some weight from not running full duals.

                          If you run Cats, make sure they are WELL shielded from long grass, but I'd recommend not running a Cat if you can avoid it. Running through long grass with a Cat will start range fires. We had a few in our area a couple years ago.

                          I'd also do a short body lift to fit bigger tires, and not mess with suspension lift. suspension lifts raise the whole CG higher while Body lift only lifts the sheet metal up instead of the body, frame, and drivetrain! Also, maybe consider cutting the Wag's fenders to fit 33" tires at minimum.

                          Comment

                          • Tinkerjeep
                            Banned
                            • Mar 01, 2009
                            • 3662

                            #14
                            Originally posted by DarkMonohue
                            Reminds me of a couple of girls I used to know...


                            Um "Sweater Girls"...? They still build those kind of girls?

                            Comment

                            • jeepdan
                              232 I6
                              • Jan 18, 2011
                              • 52

                              #15
                              Back in 1996,
                              After breaking the drivers side exhaust manifold, while trying to remove a bad air injection check valve.
                              I bought a set of ceramic coated, Edelbrock "Tubular Exhaust System" headers. Very nice! they were over $550.00 back then.
                              Anyhow, I installed all of the air injection junk onto them, kept the heater valve in place.
                              Kept the rest of the exhaust stock, with a new cat, that was dealer installed under a recall at that time.

                              With this set up, my 91 Grand Wagoneer gained 1- 2MPG.
                              I wasn't loud at all, but had that nice header tick to it.
                              2020 Gladiator Overland Gator Color (daily driver)
                              91 Grand Wagoneer (in storage)
                              67 Kaiser M715 (frame off restoration)
                              64 US Army CJ3B (frame off restoration)
                              66 M416 trailer (original "nice" condition)
                              Two unrestored 56 Willys trucks (one a pickup, one a stake bed)

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X