Swapped in the S-10 box...WOW!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Sitting Bull
    360 AMC
    • Sep 18, 2000
    • 3471

    Swapped in the S-10 box...WOW!

    I just wanted to take a minute to give a thumbs-up for the s-10 steering box swap. Got it done on Monday...WOW! What an improvement over the stock steering. The Jeep now feels just like the xj did...nice and tight. I put in one of Tad's steering braces to supplement for that 4th missing bolt. So far...I am really...really...impressed.
    Brad Reardon<br />1977ish Cherokee Chief.
  • shepherdskeep
    258 I6
    • Aug 12, 2006
    • 277

    #2
    I like my S-10 box too. Don't have the steering brace yet, but it still does great off road. Shoot, yesterday I was cruising the Chero on I-81 at 80mph and it was wonderful.
    -Rob

    Bluegill on www.4x4Grace.com

    79 Cherokee WT
    01 TJ Sport

    It's a Jeep thing!

    Comment

    • fullsizejohn
      258 I6
      • Nov 20, 2006
      • 390

      #3
      The steering box on my '79 j-10 is leaking some down by the seal above pitman arm.
      Whats the short list of what i would need to upgrade to an s-10 box??
      '77 cj-5,
      '78 j-10,(not running)
      '79 J-10 360ci,t400,D300, SOA-D60w/ARB, 14B w/Detroit,4:56s, 37" TRXUS
      '06 Ford F250 super duty crew cab

      Comment

      • mattmopar440
        AMC 4 OH! 1
        • May 17, 2007
        • 4092

        #4
        steering boxs

        mines leaking

        do they make more noise ??????
        87' Grand Wagoneer
        401/727/229, Currently:RUNNING
        84 J10/20 hybrid 258/727/208 Daily Driver
        80' J10 4BT/AX-15/208
        74' J10 Go Grabber Green Sold
        Originally posted by Heavy_Metal_Thunder_81
        Inferior Chevy

        Comment

        • Stuka
          • Jan 21, 2001
          • 13743

          #5
          Originally posted by shepherdskeep
          I like my S-10 box too. Don't have the steering brace yet, but it still does great off road. Shoot, yesterday I was cruising the Chero on I-81 at 80mph and it was wonderful.
          Funny, the stock boxes on both my jeeps were fine at 85+, never had an issue with them. I will take the extra strength of a full size steering box over the 'feel' of a 1/4 ton steering box anyday. Especially since putting a smaller steering wheel on gives it the same tight feeling.

          Comment

          • Gambler68
            Rabble Rouser
            • Feb 29, 2004
            • 14083

            #6
            Originally posted by Stuka
            Funny, the stock boxes on both my jeeps were fine at 85+, never had an issue with them. I will take the extra strength of a full size steering box over the 'feel' of a 1/4 ton steering box anyday. Especially since putting a smaller steering wheel on gives it the same tight feeling.
            agreed. I have a much smaller than jeep Grant leatherwrap wheel on mine..steer with one finger @ 70 with 33" mud tires. (but not for long)
            1979 Chero S "Sundog" 1979 Chero S "Hammer"
            1968 327 J3000 1978 J10SWB
            The Edge... there is no honest way to explain it because the only people who really know where it is are the ones who have gone over.
            Hunter S. Thompson .

            Comment

            • The Anti-Chrysler
              Disciple of A.M.C.
              • Aug 19, 2002
              • 4985

              #7
              Ahh the S10 conversion...my discovery of a few years ago....

              Nah, they are actually the same exact size, just the one bolt boss missing on the S10 box. Fullsize Chevy uses much larger bolts so those can't be used. The difference is in the ratio, and quality of the seals, etc. Besides the extra assist, I can't see how one's stronger than the other, besides the J20 box.

              S10's are 1/2 ton's as far as capacity actually, a truck rated to only hold 500lbs is kind of silly.

              The later S10 boxes are also variable ratio, which most of the FSJ's are not. You either love them or hate them, some people like the FSJ super assist, some don't. Of course it's cool either way.....


              Originally posted by Stuka
              Funny, the stock boxes on both my jeeps were fine at 85+, never had an issue with them. I will take the extra strength of a full size steering box over the 'feel' of a 1/4 ton steering box anyday. Especially since putting a smaller steering wheel on gives it the same tight feeling.
              Jason Davis
              '82 J-10 Laredo, 360, T-177, 4" Rusty's
              '85 J-10 (parts)
              '09 Pontiac G8 GT Sport, '97 Sierra (Vortec 454), '98 Silverado Z71 (5.7 Vortec)

              Comment

              • The Anti-Chrysler
                Disciple of A.M.C.
                • Aug 19, 2002
                • 4985

                #8
                Originally posted by jwwdsn
                The steering box on my '79 j-10 is leaking some down by the seal above pitman arm.
                Whats the short list of what i would need to upgrade to an s-10 box??
                Just 80+ stock FSJ power steering hoses (cause in 80+ they went to o-ring metric fittings versus the flared fittings you have now), and a steering box from a 95+ 4x4 S10 Blazer, pickup, Jimmy, Bravada, etc. As they are getting older now too, I would look for something from the 2000's era. You use your existing pitman arm on the S-10 box.

                Just keep in mind that if you like the amount of assist you have in the steering now, that will be gone for a more late model truck feel. I always disliked how much assist the stock FSJ boxes have but there's certainly plenty of guys here that feel the exact opposite, like Brandon above.
                Jason Davis
                '82 J-10 Laredo, 360, T-177, 4" Rusty's
                '85 J-10 (parts)
                '09 Pontiac G8 GT Sport, '97 Sierra (Vortec 454), '98 Silverado Z71 (5.7 Vortec)

                Comment

                • wyldwdwest
                  232 I6
                  • Aug 22, 2007
                  • 33

                  #9
                  Bracket

                  Originally posted by The Anti-Chrysler
                  Just 80+ stock FSJ power steering hoses (cause in 80+ they went to o-ring metric fittings versus the flared fittings you have now), and a steering box from a 95+ 4x4 S10 Blazer, pickup, Jimmy, Bravada, etc. As they are getting older now too, I would look for something from the 2000's era. You use your existing pitman arm on the S-10 box.

                  Just keep in mind that if you like the amount of assist you have in the steering now, that will be gone for a more late model truck feel. I always disliked how much assist the stock FSJ boxes have but there's certainly plenty of guys here that feel the exact opposite, like Brandon above.
                  They mentioned using a bracket to compensate for the fourth hole issue. Where could someone find one and how much are they? Thanks for your time.
                  Keith

                  "Some might say I'm paranoid but when you need it, and don't have it, you sing a different tune."

                  83 Wag. Limited, TFI, 3" Superlift, just getting started.

                  Comment

                  • shepherdskeep
                    258 I6
                    • Aug 12, 2006
                    • 277

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Stuka
                    Funny, the stock boxes on both my jeeps were fine at 85+, never had an issue with them. I will take the extra strength of a full size steering box over the 'feel' of a 1/4 ton steering box anyday. Especially since putting a smaller steering wheel on gives it the same tight feeling.
                    Woah now - my DD ain't no "1/4 ton" - it had 1,400lbs of AMC & Jeep parts in the bed a few weeks ago, and finally started to bottom out after carrying the parts around for a week. And my "1/4 ton" 4.3 will outpull almost any other normally aspirated 6cyl.
                    -Rob

                    Bluegill on www.4x4Grace.com

                    79 Cherokee WT
                    01 TJ Sport

                    It's a Jeep thing!

                    Comment

                    • shepherdskeep
                      258 I6
                      • Aug 12, 2006
                      • 277

                      #11
                      Originally posted by jwwdsn
                      The steering box on my '79 j-10 is leaking some down by the seal above pitman arm.
                      Whats the short list of what i would need to upgrade to an s-10 box??
                      All you need is the gearbox from a late 90's or newer 4WD S-10/S-15, everything but one hole in the FSJ frame will bolt right up.

                      Some people say it won't hold up - but I've beat my Chero hard on the trails - even broke a front leaf spring pin & ripped the upper shock mount from the frame.....but the S-10 box is still going strong.
                      Last edited by shepherdskeep; 09-04-2007, 09:50 PM.
                      -Rob

                      Bluegill on www.4x4Grace.com

                      79 Cherokee WT
                      01 TJ Sport

                      It's a Jeep thing!

                      Comment

                      • Stuka
                        • Jan 21, 2001
                        • 13743

                        #12
                        You guys are aware that 1/4 ton doesnt mean it can only haul 500 pounds, just like a half ton doesnt mean it can only haul 1000 pounds. Its the suspension rating. The S10 is a compact truck with small running gear. Just like a ranger or a tacoma/hilux.

                        Not sure what was ment above about better seals. My old cherokees seals were 32 years old and were fine. Didnt leak a drop.

                        I am sure the S10 box feels nice on the street, but I fail to see the point offroad. The extra assist that the FSJ box gives is a VERY nice thing to have offroad when you have larger than stock tires.

                        Comment

                        • Tad
                          • Nov 30, 2001
                          • 17618

                          #13
                          Glad that worked out for you Brad.
                          2000 Infinity QX4, 3.3L, MPFI, 4 speed auto, 2 speed Nissan tcase, Unibody, IFS front, 4 link rear solid axle with 255-70/16s

                          IFSJA WMS PROJECT
                          EARLY WAG LIFT SEARCH

                          ...Pay no attention to these heathen barbarians with their cutting torches and 8" lift kits!...
                          Self Inflicted Flesh Wound

                          Comment

                          • The Anti-Chrysler
                            Disciple of A.M.C.
                            • Aug 19, 2002
                            • 4985

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Stuka
                            You guys are aware that 1/4 ton doesnt mean it can only haul 500 pounds, just like a half ton doesnt mean it can only haul 1000 pounds. Its the suspension rating. The S10 is a compact truck with small running gear. Just like a ranger or a tacoma/hilux.

                            Not sure what was ment above about better seals. My old cherokees seals were 32 years old and were fine. Didnt leak a drop.

                            I am sure the S10 box feels nice on the street, but I fail to see the point offroad. The extra assist that the FSJ box gives is a VERY nice thing to have offroad when you have larger than stock tires.
                            Actually, every 4x4 S10 I've seen has a 1/2 ton rating, I don't know if there was a 1/4 ton, but not that I've seen. Not talking about what you can actually cram in there, talking GVWR. Moot point, of course.

                            I'm sure nobody would disagree that automotive seal technology has vastly improved in the last XX years???? I've owned about 10 FSJ's, and each and every one had a leaky P/S box, even low mileage vehicles. Surely they don't all, but all the ones I've had have. It's surely age-related more than anything else.

                            What I was saying above was that the swap isn't for everyone, but for some it's perfect. I completely agree, not as good for rock crawling, etc. but it shouldn't be discouraged for anyone who wants to do it, that's all.
                            Jason Davis
                            '82 J-10 Laredo, 360, T-177, 4" Rusty's
                            '85 J-10 (parts)
                            '09 Pontiac G8 GT Sport, '97 Sierra (Vortec 454), '98 Silverado Z71 (5.7 Vortec)

                            Comment

                            • Sitting Bull
                              360 AMC
                              • Sep 18, 2000
                              • 3471

                              #15
                              Well...regardless of the naysayers...I LOVE IT! I would hate to think how much money I have spent on my Jeep, but I can say this is by far the best bang-for-the-buck money I've spent.

                              I don't get the comparison saying it's a lighter duty box. The S-10 box is the same size as the SJ, the valve is just a variable ratio. From the info I gathered, the variable ratio is from 13:1 to 17:1, depending on how far the wheel is turned. The SJ box is always 17:1. The gear sizes, pitman arm, hose size, etc. are all the exact same. I used a steering brace from Tad to supplement the missing mounting hole, so now I have five points to spread out the load, where the stock configuration only has 4.

                              But regardless, I dropped the "only-increase-in-off-road-performance-counts" quite a while ago. I wheel a few times a year...but I take the family on little jaunts in it quite often. I built this to have fun with in a variety of situations...if I built it only to wheel...I certainly would do things different. But for the Jeeper that uses it as utilitarian vehicle instead of off-road-only...this is great. I go to Home Depot alot more often than I go to Tellico. When I'm at Tellico, I'll be comfortable turning the wheel a little harder. But when I'm driving to and from Tellico...I'll be smiling from ear to ear.

                              The variable ratio makes a HUGE difference at highway speeds. To me anyway...this is a great compromise for streetability.
                              Last edited by Sitting Bull; 09-05-2007, 06:28 AM.
                              Brad Reardon<br />1977ish Cherokee Chief.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X